• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
HSG Advisors

HSG Advisors

Building High-Performing Physician Networks

MENUMENU
  • Home
  • About HSG
    • About HSG
      • Shared Vision
      • Leadership Team
    • Careers
  • Healthcare Consulting
    • Physician Strategy
      • Health System Strategic Plans
      • Employed Physician Network Strategy
      • Physician Growth Strategy
      • Shared Vision and Culture Development
      • Physician Manpower Plans
      • Service Line Strategy
      • Physician Co-Management
    • Physician Leadership
      • Shared Vision and Culture Development
      • Physician Burnout
      • Physician Governance and Leadership
    • Performance Improvement
      • Network Performance Improvement
      • Performance Improvement Implementation
      • Network Revenue Cycle
      • Practice Care Model Transformation
      • Practice Acquisitions
      • Advanced Practice Provider (APP) Utilization
      • Virtual Health
    • Network Integrity
      • Patient Share of Care
      • Patient Flow
      • Provider Service Location Analysis
      • Market Insight
      • Physician Network Intelligence
    • Physician Compensation
      • Compensation Plan Design
      • Fair Market Value and Commercial Reasonableness Opinions
      • Advanced Practice Provider (APP) Compensation
      • Medicare Physician Fee Schedule
  • Thought Leadership
  • Contact Us
  • Medicare Changes
  • Client Log-In
Client Log-In LinkedIn LinkedIn

Contact Us

Employed Provider Networks and Health Systems May Suffer Under One Physician Executive Leader

HSG strongly encourages clients to consider two distinct physician executive leaders, over health system and employed provider network.

December 9, 2020 by D.J. Sullivan

Two Physician Executives.pdf Two Physician Executives
Download The Article To Share With Your Team

Dual Physician Executive Leaders: Hospital/Health System and Employed Provider Network

Hospitals and health systems who desire a physician executive presence within the hospital/health system and within the employed provider network often debate whether they really need two physician executives. They often ask HSG, “Can’t a single individual fulfill both roles?”

A defining consideration in this internal debate is whether the organization “can afford” to have two positions. Though often thought of in terms of positions, affordability is actually a function of FTEs rather than the roles fulfilled. HSG strongly encourages clients to consider two distinct leaders but not necessarily two FTEs.

The basis for this recommendation resides in the differing emphases and functionalities of the two roles in question. Hospitals and health systems should consider a high-level overview of the two positions in question.

Position #1: Hospital/Health System Physician Executive

The hospital/health system physician executive position needs to maintain a global focus across the breadth of hospital/health system functions (including system level service line performance and development), and external organizational interactions including hospital regulatory relationships and independent physicians.

Position #2: Employed Provider Network Physician Executive

The employed provider network physician executive position often exists within a dyad leadership/management relationship with an administrative Executive Director. The position involves direct operational support of the employed provider network and development of strategic capabilities of the group. This position often fulfills the desire to have physicians report to physicians and unify the reporting structure through the leadership dyad.

Most organizations that attempt this dual coverage, one position arrangement find that this solution does not function well due to the different and, at times, conflicting role expectations. Consider the following potential unintended consequences of a single individual covering each of the positions:

Clouded Reporting Structure

It may not be clear which “hat” the physician executive is wearing during any given interaction. Adding to this factor can be perceived conflicts of interest, perhaps most notably with addressing concerns related to hospital v. employed network and independent v. employed physician perspectives.

Differing Scope

As noted above, the hospital/health system physician executive must maintain a high level of objectivity across the system and must focus on the entirety of system services and function. In contrast , the employed network physician executive narrowly focuses on the employed network operations and strategy – only peripherally bringing hospital or system issues to others’ attention.

Excessive Scope

The expansive nature of each position’s responsibilities and functions invariably competes for the amount of time an individual can focus on either area. Both areas require significant focus. Invariably, system priorities take precedence at the expense of network involvement.

Burnout Risk

The demands on excessive scope, conflicting priorities, and differing focuses can contribute to the risk
of physician executive positional dissatisfaction, poor performance, and burnout. The circumstances can lead to frequent positional turnover and destabilization of the entire organization.

Expecting a single physician executive to fulfill the roles and responsibilities inherent in both the hospital/health system and employed provider network physician executive positions frequently leads to group dysfunction and role dissatisfaction.

The system should strongly consider investing in separate physician executives for the hospital/health system and employed provider network positions to maximize group and individual function and stability. This recommendation does not imply that two full time positions are recommended – just two separate positions. The portion of FTEs attributed to each position will directly depend on the size and complexity of the involved entities.

Related Physician Leadership Content

9 Elements of An Employed Physician Group Shared Vision White Paper
5 Common Physician Leadership Council Mistakes

Category iconArticles,  Physician Leadership

Primary Sidebar

Terrence R. McWilliams, MD, FAAFP

(502) 614-4292 tmcwilliams@hsgadvisors.com

Receive Physician Strategy News

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Recent Thought Leadership

  • HSG Claims Data Analytics Updates: February 2023
  • 2023 Medicare Physician Fee Schedule Updates
  • HSG Advisors Expands Consulting Services and Data Analytics Capabilities in Response to National Outpatient Utilization Trend
  • Creating a Win/Win System of Advanced Practice Provider Oversight
  • Employed Provider Network Shared Vision: Process and Intent

Insights for Confident Leaders

Sign Up for HSG's Physician Strategy News™ and Notifications on New Thought Leadership
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Footer

9850 Von Allmen Court
Suite 201
Louisville, Kentucky 40241

(502) 814-1180

info@HSGadvisors.com

  • Physician Strategy
  • Physician Leadership
  • Performance Improvement
  • Network Integrity
  • Physician Compensation
  • About HSG
  • Purchase HSG’s Book
  • Leadership Team
  • Careers at HSG
  • Thought Leadership
  • Privacy Policy

Take HSG’s Physician Network Evaluation Survey
Get Started Here

  • LinkedIn
  • Vimeo

© 2023 HSG Advisors. Website managed by SiteCare.com